A converged CFD solution is a starting point. Numerical checks and comparison with physical evidence answer different questions about a model.

DEEB-FLOW concept illustration of a heat-transfer experiment and numerical comparison
Ilustración conceptual interactiva: el coeficiente de transferencia de calor local a lo largo de un tubo calentado, según el caso DEEB-FLOW. Mueva el puntero para refinar la malla de 4 a 32 celdas: los escalones calculados convergen hacia su curva independiente de la malla (discontinua), y la lectura indica el índice de convergencia de malla. La diferencia que queda frente a los puntos medidos y sus barras de incertidumbre es lo que evalúa la validación. Los valores son ilustrativos.

Este artículo todavía no está disponible en su idioma; se muestra en inglés.

Verification examines the numerical calculation

Verification asks whether the numerical solution represents the mathematical model with sufficient accuracy for the intended use. Residual behaviour, conservation balances and the stability of engineering outputs are relevant checks. A small residual alone does not establish that pressure loss, heat transfer or another decision variable is insensitive to numerical choices.

Mesh sensitivity is about quantities that matter

Refine the mesh systematically and compare the same engineering quantities under consistent physical conditions. Watch where refinement changes the answer, particularly near walls, jets, interfaces and steep gradients. Where appropriate, a grid-convergence study can help estimate discretisation uncertainty. Agreement between two meshes is useful evidence, but is not experimental validation.

Validation compares the model with physical evidence

Validation considers how well the chosen physical model describes the real system for its intended use. Compare with relevant measurements under matching operating conditions, with measurement uncertainty in view. Matching a single measured quantity does not prove that every internal field is correct or that the model is reliable outside the conditions examined.

Report the limits alongside the conclusion

Record assumptions, boundary conditions, numerical checks and the conditions covered by the evidence. Separate numerical uncertainty from uncertain inputs and modelling limitations. If relevant measurements are unavailable, say so and define what a future test should measure. The useful outcome is a decision supported by stated evidence, not an unqualified claim that the model is validated.

Fuentes y lecturas adicionales

Servicio relacionado

Revisión de modelos y estudios a medida

Saber qué respalda el modelo, dónde persiste la incertidumbre y qué debe verificarse.

Explorar servicios
Todos los artículos